Spite Houses: When Real Estate Grudges Become Brick-and-Mortar (and Why Title Pros Care)
By: Luke Noble
An autumn stroll through the darker corners of real estate history.
As the days grow shorter and the air cools, even those of us in the title and settlement world can appreciate a good ghost story, especially when the ghosts are legal ones: lingering easements, missing heirs, or century-old grudges recorded right into the land records. Some of those grudges, it turns out, became real houses.
Meet the spite house a property built less for comfort and more for payback. From narrow alleys sealed in brick to grand manors erected purely to needle a rival, these homes stand as both curiosities and cautionary tales. They remind us that every deed tells a story, and some of those stories are best read before the ink dries.
Below, we’ll tour four notorious examples. Consider it a seasonal walk through real estate’s slightly haunted side, each case offering a lesson in why thorough title work, accurate surveys, and a good sense of history can save you from your own fright night at closing.
- Hollensbury Spite House (Alexandria, VA) – 1830
John Hollensbury’s Alley Warfare
Our first stop takes us to Alexandria, Virginia where autumn leaves drift between centuries-old rowhouses and one narrow sliver of brick barely wide enough for a broom. In 1830, brickmaker and city councilman John Hollensbury decided he’d had enough of wagon hubs scraping his walls and loiterers cluttering his alley. His solution? Enclose the alley entirely, turning it into a house only seven feet, six inches wide.
Whether he meant to keep the peace, irk his neighbor, or simply amuse his daughters, the result endures as the “Hollensbury Spite House” a piece of living architectural sarcasm that still stands today.
Title Takeaway:
Alleys, “paper streets,” and implied easements are a hydra of headaches for underwriters and examiners alike. If that narrow passage had been subject to a recorded right-of-way or city interest, Hollensbury’s quick-brick fix could have sparked litigation lasting generations. The moral: alleys aren’t empty space. Confirm fee ownership, check every easement, and never assume that a blank spot on a plat is free for the taking.
- The Skinny House (Boston, MA) – c. 1870s
From Family Feud to Urban Legend
A few hundred miles north, where the first chills of a Boston October cut through the harbor breeze, another slender home casts its long shadow. The Skinny House on Hull Street at just 10 feet wide at the front has inspired countless retellings. The favorite version? Two brothers feuded over inherited land, and one built a narrow four-story structure to block the other’s view and sunlight.
Recent research, however, suggests the feud might be more folklore than fact. Land records and historic maps point to later construction and ownership patterns that don’t quite match the tale. Still, myths have a way of attaching themselves to property like stubborn liens.
Title Takeaway:
Urban infill lots and tight parcels raise familiar questions: Who maintains the party wall? Are there air, light, or access easements? When stories and documents conflict, only one holds up in court, the recorded one. The “Skinny House” underscores how lore can outlive paperwork, and how title professionals serve as the ultimate truth-seekers in untangling what’s myth, what’s record, and what’s insurable.
- The McCobb “Spite House” (Rockport, ME) – 1806
A Family Feud, a Floating Mansion, and a Lesson in Heirship
As we follow the crisp coastal wind up to Maine, our next example looms larger and grander. Sea Captain Thomas McCobb, having lost his expected inheritance of the family homestead, decided to build a home so magnificent it would eclipse the one that slipped through his grasp. The result: a stunning Federal-style mansion locals dubbed the “Spite House.”
But the story didn’t end there. In 1925, long after McCobb’s passing, the house itself was moved by barge some 85 miles to Rockport’s Deadman’s Point, a name fit for this season if there ever was one. Today, the McCobb Spite House remains a National Register landmark and a masterclass in how property (and pride) can travel far.
Title Takeaway:
Family conveyances and inheritance disputes still drive a startling number of title defects. Add to that a structure literally relocated across the water, and you invite questions about whether the house’s legal description, covenants, or easements “float” along (spoiler: they don’t). Land rights stay with land. Before insuring, always verify the current legal description and clear any lingering encumbrances that may have washed ashore from a prior parcel.
- Tyler Spite House (Frederick, MD) – 1814
Blocking Progress—Literally
Finally, we return south to Frederick, Maryland, where falling leaves gather in front of an elegant brick building said to have been born of one man’s defiance. In 1814, Dr. John Tyler allegedly began building his house directly in the path of a planned public road, exploiting a local ordinance that prohibited cutting through an active construction site. By the time the city could reroute, his house was already a permanent fixture and the road never came.
The property later became apartments and then a B&B, but the legend remains: a homeowner outmaneuvering City Hall with a hammer and a grudge.
Title Takeaway:
When private property meets public intent, the result can haunt records for decades. Title pros should scrutinize dedications, acceptances, and street vacations carefully, those “roads that never were” often linger on old plats, muddying today’s commitments. It’s a reminder that even the most civic-minded maps can hide a trick beneath the treat.
Threading the Needle: What These Stories Share
Across these four spite-soaked examples, whether it’s a sealed alley in Virginia, a razor-thin brownstone in Boston, a wandering mansion in Maine, or a road-blocking rebel in Maryland a common thread runs deeper than the autumn chill: property law is permanent. Every grudge, mistake, or missing signature can echo across generations.
For those working around the closing table, the takeaways are timeless (and seasonally apt):
- Alleys aren’t “empty space.” Verify ownership and recorded easements for ingress, egress, and maintenance. Many a grudge began where someone assumed a void.
- Survey early, survey always. Sliver lots, tapering walls, and encroachments can turn into real horror shows at underwriting time.
- Trust records over folklore. Great stories make great walking tours but only documents make insurable property.
- Heirs and homesteads haunt closings. Family disputes leave long shadows. Track down every heir and release.
- Watch the edge between public and private. Paper streets, unaccepted plats, and forgotten dedications can still rise from the dead.
- Mind setbacks and zoning. Even “grandfathered” oddities may not survive a renovation. Always flag risk for counsel review.
Closing Thought
As Halloween approaches and twilight creeps a little earlier each day, it’s worth remembering that the strangest structures on the block often sprang from very human emotions, resentment, pride, revenge. Spite houses may make for charming folklore and Instagram fodder, but they’re also cautionary markers of what happens when property disputes go unexamined.
In our business, the cure is simple but powerful: sound title work, smart surveys, and a paper trail as clear as a crisp October morning. Because whether your next closing involves a grand estate or a seven-foot-wide shoebox, clear title remains the best neighbor you’ll ever have.
Anderson|Biro is a full-service, Executive Search firm dedicated nationally to the Financial Services sector. We source talent to service all aspects of the Built World, including the Land Title Insurance, Settlement and Appraisal industries. We have forged successful partnerships with leading Homebuilders, iBuyers, Fintech, Servicers, Law Firms, Real Estate Brokerages, Private Equity and Lenders with direct or indirect stakes around the real estate closing table. We offer quality solutions for clients in these primary fields and beyond. Our candidates are screened for specific industry experience, outstanding track records, and values that complement your mission and culture.